Best BBQ in the Finger Lakes 🍖
Welcome to the smoky, saucy side of the Finger Lakes. From roadside pits to family-run smokehouses, this region is full of BBQ gems you might not expect. Whether you’re after brisket, ribs, or pulled pork, we’ve scouted out five must-try spots that serve up the best BBQ in the Finger Lakes.
Looking for the best BBQ near Ithaca, Watkins Glen, or Geneva? These are our top picks — with a side of flavor and a map to help you get there.
🔥 Featured Spot
Your BBQ – Your Town
A Finger Lakes favorite featured spot could be yours! Contact us today.
📍 View on Google Maps
🕒 Open ?
🌟 Editor’s Pick
🏆 Top 5 Finger Lakes BBQ Joints
1. Smokin Petes – Geneva
Smokin’ Petes is classic roadside BBQ done right — big portions, bold flavors, and all the smoky goodness you’d expect from a place with a dedicated local following. The pulled pork sandwich is a must, but regulars swear by the brisket and homemade sides. Grab a picnic table and dig in just a short drive from Watkins Glen, Geneva, or Penn Yan.
🕒 Open Wed–Sun
2. State Bakery & BBQ – Newfield
Don’t let the name fool you — this bakery does BBQ right. The pit comes alive with wood-fired brisket, ribs, and pulled pork, and more, all served alongside their fresh baked goods. It’s part bakery, part BBQ heaven — and entirely worth the trip.
📍 View on Google Maps
🕒 Open Thurs–Sun
3. Nickel’s Pit BBQ – Watkins Glen
A Finger Lakes favorite just steps from the marina, Nickel’s delivers smoky perfection with brisket, ribs, and house-made sauces. Come for the BBQ, stay for the live music and local beer.
🕒 Open Wed–Sun
📍 BBQ Map
(Map coming soon — for now, click links above for directions)
About Finger Lakes Effect
We’re your Finger Lakes local guide to everything great in the Finger Lakes — from tasty food to the best hiking trails and events. Want more like this? Subscribe to our free newsletter for weekly tips, events, and insider picks.