| Distance | Difficulty | Est. Time | Surface | Trail Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.5 miles | Moderate | 1.5–2 hours | Natural (dirt, grass, seasonal mud) | Out & Back or Lollipop Loop |
Trail Overview
Tucked inside the High Tor Wildlife Management Area, the Italy Hill Trail offers a wild and rugged hike that feels far from civilization. The trail meanders through lush forest, seasonal streams, and old-growth stands before looping or doubling back depending on the conditions. If you’re into quiet trails with a remote vibe, this one’s a great pick.
This is a great spot for solitude, birdwatching, and seeing a more untamed side of the Finger Lakes region — especially in spring and fall when the forest is alive with sound or color.
What You’ll See
- Dense forest and fern-covered ground
- Seasonal creek crossings and mud
- Plenty of wildlife (birds, deer, frogs)
- Quiet, overgrown atmosphere (rarely crowded)
- Occasional open glades or powerline cut views
Trail Notes
- Trailhead: Access via Italy Valley Road — look for small parking pulloffs or unmarked trail access
- Best Season: Late spring through fall; avoid during muddy shoulder seasons unless you’re geared for it
- Trail Surface: Mostly dirt, some wet or overgrown spots — bring waterproof boots
- Dogs: Allowed on leash
- Important: This trail is minimally marked and can feel like a bushwhack in parts — GPS/map recommended
- Pro Tip: Pair it with a visit to nearby Grimes Glen or enjoy a scenic drive through Italy Valley for maximum Finger Lakes enjoyment
Maps and Info
🚶♀️ Explore More Finger Lakes Trails
Love trails like this?
Subscribe to The Finger Lakes Effect for weekly local trail guides, events, and insider tips — delivered straight to your inbox.
Or check out more Best Finger Lakes Trails!
